A dry read for sure and somewhat dated being published in 1979, but of interest for a number of reasons: it covered the period that I was in Secondary School, it provided a good insight into the detail behind such a study (and how people worked in pre internet days), and in many ways it remains relevant for the school children of today.
Can a good school help its students overcome the adverse effects of economic disadvantage and family adversity? Recent educational assessment suggests that the answer may be a painful no. Here, however, is a book that contradicts the prevailing pessimism about the possibilities of education. In Fifteen Thousand Hours, Michael Rutter and his colleagues show conclusively that schools can make a difference.In a three-year study of a dozen secondary schools in a large urban area, Rutter’s team found that some schools were demonstrably better than others at promoting the academic and social success of their students. Moreover, there were clear and interesting differences between the schools that promote success and the schools that promote failure. As Rutter shows, these differences provide important clues to the kind of educational reform that might allow inner-city schools to act more uniformly as a positive and protective influence on students who must grow up in an otherwise disordered and difficult world.For a dozen years during their formative period of development, children spend as many of their working hours at school as at home–some 15,000 hours in all. To suggest that this tremendous amount of time has no effect on development seems irrational. To settle for schools that simply act as institutions of containment for disadvantaged children seems a strategy of despair. The importance of this major book in education is its clear demonstration that these are not the only alternatives.Michael Rutter & Colleagues
The big question for me is how relevant for today’s society, with respect to the children and the role of the schools.
I will find out more in coming months, but my perception is that the school has had far more responsibility pushed on it from parents, government and society and this needs to change.
I am also convinced that children of today are vastly different to the child I was and grew up with!